The short answer? Regularly and promptly show your donors that they’re making a difference and give them opportunities to give according to their passions and interests.
The sad truth is that most non-profits don’t treat a donor any differently until they get to the major gifts level. And even then, sometimes there is very little difference in the level of reporting back. When mid-level donors don’t see the impact of their giving, it’s nearly impossible to move them up the pipeline, let alone retain them.
In a healthy non-profit donor pipeline, donors are moving through the various giving levels easily and without clogs. Clogs are where donors get stuck, and you see large amounts of donors with little to no year-over-year growth in their giving. This often happens in the mid-level range, which is why we emphasize the importance of a mid-level program when talking about creating a healthy major gifts program.